The term “blog” is outdated these days. But, for all intents and purposes, that’s what By Common Consent is. It became popular during a time when Mormon blogs were popping up left and right. Now, a lot of them have fizzled out. But, with tens of thousands of hits each week, By Common Consent is as strong as ever.
Steve Evans, who started the site 13 years ago, says its popularity is “sort of miraculous.”
“This is not a time for blogs," he said. "It's not a time for long form reading of any kind. But that's exactly what we try to bring.”
Steve Evans is a father and an attorney. Meaning, he’s busy. But the site has always been a priority for him, as well as the the accompanying Twitter account. If you follow “BCC” then you’ve seen Evans’ snarkier side — it’s a mix of scripture and pop culture references, sometimes in ALL CAPS. (BCC is insistent that “Kid A” is Radiohead’s best album, in case you were curious.)
Snarkiness aside, there’s a distinct purpose to the blog.
“The goal is to is to look at the questions that you've always had at church but never had the time or the opportunity to really ask," he said. "Or to have discussions that you might have started with somebody but never had the time to finish.”
Contributors to the site are hand-selected and include professors, scientists and authors. Some of them have been writing about Mormon issues for decades, others are just starting out.
The name “By Common Consent” was carefully chosen as well. It’s a phrase taken from Mormon scripture, the Doctrine and Covenants to be exact. There’s a verse that states, “All things shall be done by common consent in the church.”
Meaning, when it comes to policy changes, leadership appointments or major decisions, the consent of all Mormons matter. And this website is, in a way, holding the LDS Church to that. They weigh in on all those things and don’t shy away from controversy.
Evans is not offended when a reader thinks a post is a little out of line. At times, he agrees with them. They turn posts around quickly and they sometimes get things wrong. He is the first to admit that he, and his fellow writers, can’t read the minds of LDS Church leaders. When it comes to the origin or intent behind a policy or teaching, they are speculating alongside everyone else. But he sees value in that speculation, in raising questions.
At times a post on the website has created real ripples. Like when Cynthia Lee, a computer science lecturer at Stanford, wrote about the fact that women never pray in the LDS Church’s bi-annual General Conference. She argued that there was no doctrinal significance to that decision, women were simply being excluded.
That story was posted in October of 2011. Then, a year and a half later, it happened. The first woman prayed during General Conference. Evans doesn’t give this article all the credit, but he thinks it got the conversation started.
Evans has also used By Common Consent as an outlet for his own thoughts. For example, back in November 2015 when the LDS Church announced that the children of gay couples could not be baptized, he turned to the site to work through it.
“It's one of those things that I don't understand and I don't expect to understand," he said. "It’s something that I'm not okay with. Being able to write about it and say that I'm not okay with it, that I don't understand it, and that it affects friends and families, that is enormously cathartic for me.”
By Common Consent serves as proof of the kind of Mormon community Evans is most proud of — a place where you can truly speak your mind.
“If you harbor these things, if you don't have anywhere to talk about them and if you've got nowhere to go then you’re left with a binary choice: You have to leave. And I think that's a false choice. I think there is room within my faith to talk about difficult things and to disagree, even disagree with leadership on some things. And it's just enormously comforting to know that there is a place where these ideas can be thrashed out altogether.”
Editor's note: This post has been updated to correct an error. By Common Consent was created 13 years ago, not 17.