Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
Updates from NPR on the Trump rally shooting and assassination attempt
Find KUER's reporting on the races, candidates and more for Utah’s 2018 midterm elections. Click here for our graphics of the U.S. Senate race, 4 Congressional races and Utah ballot initiatives.

Candidates In 1st District Debate Public Lands, National Debt And Civility

Photo of candidates at debate.
Eli Lucero / The Herald Journal

Candidates for Utah’s 1st Congressional District debate scuffled over public lands, immigration and the national debt on Wednesday night in a wide-ranging debate that pitted eight-term GOP incumbent Rob Bishop against two challengers.

“Washington sucks, but it’s not nearly as bad as what you hear all the time,” said Bishop on a question about civility and lack of bipartisanship in Washington.  

Bishop faced off against Democrat Lee Castillo, a social worker, and Eric Eliason of the newly formed moderate United Utah Party at Utah State University in Logan in their first and only debate for a seat representing the district that stretches from Box Elder to Uintah County.

The eight-term Republican is seeking what he says will be his final term in Congress.

As chairman of the powerful House Resources Committee, Bishop has led legislative efforts for the kind of deregulation the Trump Administration has advocated.

Long a proponent of giving states more discretion over public land decisions, Bishop applauded the Trump administration’s move to scale back the Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments.

“What President Trump did is actually a compromise, I think people should look at that,” Bishop said in response to a question about the monuments rollback. “By taking those areas that really did have historic value, leaving those as monuments, and the rest is left [under] BLM control.”

But Eliason said he questioned Bishop’s motives in supporting plans that could reopen parts of the original Grand Staircase-Escalante monument to extractive industries.

“His committee has received $6 million from the oil and gas industry,” said Eliason. “I have a hard time seeing how our congressman can be objective when that is the case. He says he has our back — I question that.”

Eliason was the only third party candidate to qualify for the Utah Debate Commission’s five televised congressional debates after gaining enough support.   

Eliason sought to distinguish himself from Bishop and Castillo with a more middle-of-the-road platform on issues such as health care and immigration.

On the increasing national debt, Bishop said it was a problem of spending, not the GOP’s recent tax cuts — an argument that was quickly rebutted by Democrat Lee Castillo.

“We cannot continue to bear the burden for our children, and our children’s children, because these people want to give the top 1 percent a tax break that doesn’t expire — but your middle class tax breaks do expire,” he said.

Both Castillo and Eliason face long odds in Utah’s 1st District, among the most conservative in the country, according to the Cook Partisan Political Report.

In a Salt Lake Tribune poll released on Wednesday, Bishop was shown with a more than 30-point lead over Castillo and Eliason.

Bishop, in his closing remarks, asked voters to allow him a swan song in Congress to continue working on issues for the district.

“I ask for your vote, you’ve been very kind to me [in] the past, one last time, because this will be my last term, and I want to be the leader of that team,” said Bishop.


Julia joined KUER in 2016 after a year reporting at the NPR member station in Reno, Nev. During her stint, she covered battleground politics, school overcrowding, and any story that would take her to the crystal blue shores of Lake Tahoe. Her work earned her two regional Edward R. Murrow awards. Originally from the mountains of Western North Carolina, Julia graduated from UNC-Chapel Hill in 2008 with a degree in journalism. She’s worked as both a print and radio reporter in several states and several countries — from the 2008 Beijing Olympics to Dakar, Senegal. Her curiosity about the American West led her to take a spontaneous, one-way road trip to the Great Basin, where she intends to continue preaching the gospel of community journalism, public radio and podcasting. In her spare time, you’ll find her hanging with her beagle Bodhi, taking pictures of her food and watching Patrick Swayze movies.
KUER is listener-supported public radio. Support this work by making a donation today.